Stewart Information Services Corporation (STC) - Due Diligence

hourglass

Caricamento company...

Sto preparando dati, stili e contenuti aggiornati della DD.

69OpportunityDD: Jun 30, 2026Analyst: 76

paidPrice

$67.06

domainMkt cap

$2.04B

pie_chartShares

30.43M

candlestick_chart52W

$56.39-$78.61

trending_downShort interest

2.6%

INFONYSETitle Insurance & Real Estate Services8000 employees

Verdict: Moderately Attractive — Fair value close to current price

Quality cyclical title-insurance franchise with strong Q1 2026 momentum (revenue +28% YoY, adj EPS $0.78 vs $0.53 est, +47%). Trades at fwd P/E ~11x with peer median ~10x; growth premium largely priced in. Modest base-case upside (+8–10%) but solid downside floor from cash position, low debt and stable dividend (3.1% yield). VALUE screen confirmed; risk/reward symmetric, not asymmetric.

📊 DIANALITICS RESEARCH INDEXCompany & Thesis Assessment Score /100 — updated 2026-06-30

Stewart Information Services (STC)

Title Insurance · NYSE · Houston, TX

"Quality value, fairly priced — fundamentals improving but upside capped by peer-compression."

Q1 +28% rev D/E 0.39 Housing-cycle play Dividend 3.1% Smallest of Big-4

Fin. strength

/20 pts

EBITDA/FCF

/15 pts

Debt/leverage

/15 pts

Stage/business

/15 pts

Catalysts

/10 pts

Reg. risk

/8 pts

Risk/reward

/7 pts

Management

/5 pts

Sector/macro

/3 pts

Compliance

/2 pts

💡 Fair Value Estimate — Peer-derived P/E (4 title insurers comparables)

Fair value base case

USD 72.5

Range: USD 55.0-USD 95.0

Current price ~USD 67.1

Base upside/downside: +8%

Methodology: Forward P/E built bottom-up from peer median (9.6x) + quantified growth premium (+1.4x) + M&A accretion (NAN) + cycle option. Implied multiple 12.4x within peer ceiling. Cross-check P/B method within ±5%. Sensitivity to ±1x multiple = ±8%, to ±10% EPS = ±10%; FV is robust. Probability-weighted EV = 0.20×$95 + 0.50×$73 + 0.30×$55 = $72.0/sh. Expected return = +7.4% vs $67.06 close. Modest upside, symmetric risk: this is fair-value territory, not deep value. ⚠️ Not investment advice.

Component	Assumption	USD/share
Core earnings value	FY26E EPS $5.85 × 9.6x peer-median fwd P/E (FNF 7.9 / FAF 9.4 / ORI 11.4)	+56.16
Growth premium	+1.4x P/E uplift (Q1'26 rev +28% vs peers ~10% YoY) × $5.85 EPS	+8.19
M&A accretion (NAN)	Nationwide Appraisal Network adds ~$0.25 FY27E EPS × 10.8x	+2.70
Housing-cycle option value	30% probability × $20/sh upside from existing-home sales normalization	+6.00
Cyclical reserve haircut	−10% scenario weight × $5 mortgage-rate sensitivity	−0.55
FV base case	Sum of components above (peer-median + growth + M&A + cycle − haircut)	≈ $72.50

Bull

$90–100

Probability: 20%

Fed cuts in 2H'26, existing-home sales rebound from cycle lows, STC reaches FY27 EPS $7.50 at 13x = $97. Commercial title segment maintains record growth, NAN integration accretive ahead of schedule.

Base

$68–78

Probability: 50%

Continued mortgage-rate plateau, gradual housing normalization, FY26 EPS $5.85 × 12x = $70. Commercial title growth offsets residential weakness; dividend maintained at $2.10/yr.

Bear

$50–60

Probability: 30%

Housing recession deepens, mortgage rates re-accelerate, FY26 EPS reverts to $4.50 × 9.5x = $43–55. Multiple compression to peer median, sector de-rating; dividend cover thins but maintained.

Methodology: Methodology: Forward P/E built bottom-up from peer median (9.6x) + quantified growth premium (+1.4x) + M&A accretion (NAN) + cycle option. Implied multiple 12.4x within peer ceiling. Cross-check P/B method within ±5%. Sensitivity to ±1x multiple = ±8%, to ±10% EPS = ±10%; FV is robust. Probability-weighted EV = 0.20×$95 + 0.50×$73 + 0.30×$55 = $72.0/sh. Expected return = +7.4% vs $67.06 close. Modest upside, symmetric risk: this is fair-value territory, not deep value. ⚠️ Not investment advice. Not investment advice.

⚠️ Methodology note: P/E-based valuation derived from a 3-peer comparables grid (FNF, FAF, ORI). Multiple anchored to peer median fwd P/E (9.6x) with quantified premium for above-peer revenue growth and recent accretive M&A (Nationwide Appraisal Network). The VALUE classification is a screening criterion only; FV is built bottom-up from data and concludes the stock is fairly priced.

📊 Capital Structure · Short Interest · Buyback & Dilution

🟢 Short Interest

~2.6%

~720K shares short on ~28M float (Feb 2026). Days-to-cover 1.7. Low — no squeeze setup, no bearish positioning by hedge funds. Institutional ownership 96.9%.

🟡 Share dilution (1Y)

+9.1%

From 27.9M to 30.43M shares — equity raise in Q4 2025 financed NCS / Nationwide Appraisal acquisitions. Diluted but EPS still grew on operating leverage.

⚪ Buyback

No active buyback program. Capital priority: dividend ($64M/yr at current rate), M&A integration, balance-sheet flexibility. Could activate post-NCS digestion.

Short Interest — context

STC — 2.6%

2.6%

Insider transactions L12M: $63.9K bought / $783.5K sold (net seller −$719K). Magnitude modest (option exercises / 10b5-1 plans), not a red flag but not a vote of confidence either. Insider holding 2.94% — typical for a 130+ year old mid-cap. No Class Period; no SEC investigation; no shelf registration filed.

$Financial analysis — FY 2023–2026E

FY25 Revenue

$2.93B

+17.6% YoY

FY25 Net Income

$115.5M

+57.6% YoY

Cash (FY25)

$321.8M

vs $445.9M total debt → modest net debt

D/E Ratio

0.39

Conservative, well below 1.0

Item	FY2023	FY2024	FY2025	Q1 2026	Guidance 2026
Revenue ($M)	2,259	2,492	2,930	781	~3,300–3,500E
Net Income ($M)	−13.9	73.3	115.5	17.0	~150–175E
Adj EPS ($)	−0.51	2.69	4.05	0.78	~5.50–6.30E
Pre-tax margin	0.4%	4.6%	5.7%	6.3%	~6.5–7.0%E
Cash ($M)	251	282	322	~310	—
Long-term debt ($M)	446	446	446	446	Stable

FY24 was bottom of mortgage-volume cycle; FY25 showed 18% revenue rebound and net income +58%. Q1 2026 sustained momentum (rev +28% YoY) with broad-based growth across Title, Real Estate Solutions, and International segments.

Quarterly dynamics — last 5 quarters
Metric	Q1 2025	Q2 2025	Q3 2025	Q4 2025	Q1 2026
Revenue ($M)	612	721	807	791	781
Gross margin %	5.4%	6.1%	6.5%	6.8%	6.3%
Net income ($M)	2.8	27.5	49.0	36.3	17.0
Cash EOP ($M)	265	290	305	322	~310

Financial position and sustainability

Dividend yield (TTM)

3.13%

ROE (TTM)

8.52%

Q1 2026 EPS beat vs consensus

+47%

D/E vs sector average (1.0)

0.39

account_tree

Business model — Title insurance & real-estate services

Title insurance + adjacent real-estate services — pure-play cyclical leader

Founded 1893, Stewart underwrites residential and commercial title insurance, closing/settlement and tax-deferred-exchange services. Big-4 player (with FNF, FAF, ORI) in a regulated, state-by-state oligopoly. Revenue tied to existing-home sales, mortgage refinancing volumes and commercial real-estate transactions — pure cyclical exposure to the US housing market. Q1 2026 results showed acceleration on all fronts (commercial revenue at record levels, residential normalizing, international segment growing). Recent acquisitions (NCS in 2025, Nationwide Appraisal in April 2026) expand the appraisal/valuation footprint into adjacent fee-pool.

Title Insurance (core) ~$2,100M FY26E (~62% rev) 🟢 ramping Residential + commercial title policies. Q1 2026 commercial set record. Cyclical, GM target ~7-9% mid-cycle. Sensitive to mortgage rates and home sales volume. Real Estate Solutions ~$900M FY26E (~26% rev) 🟢 ramping Appraisal, valuation, credit, closing services. Recently boosted by Nationwide Appraisal Network deal. Higher-margin fee-based revenue, less cyclical than title. International & Other ~$400M FY26E (~12% rev) 🟡 to monitor Canada, UK, Australia operations plus digital platform services (Virtual Underwriter). Growth uneven; FX-exposed; competitive.

gavel

Legal, regulatory and risk analysis

Mortgage-rate / housing-cycle exposure

High

Title revenue ~90% tied to US home sales and refinancing. 30Y mortgage rates at ~6.5–7% still depress volumes vs 2021 peak. Any re-acceleration of rates would compress earnings sharply; revenue elasticity to housing volume is ~1.0x.

M&A integration risk (NCS + NAN)

Moderate

Two acquisitions in 18 months (NCS 2025, Nationwide Appraisal April 2026). Integration risk on systems, customer retention, expected synergies. Equity raise (+9% dilution) financed deals; accretion needs to materialize for thesis to work.

Sub-scale vs Big-3 competitors

Moderate

STC is the smallest Big-4 (mkt cap $2B vs FNF $15B, ORI $11B, FAF $7B). Less scale = thinner margins (5-7% pre-tax vs FNF 12%+), less pricing power with national lenders, less tech R&D budget vs FNF/FAF AI investments.

State-level regulatory price caps

Moderate

Title insurance is state-regulated; some states (TX, FL, NM) set rates; others have rebating restrictions. Periodic rate reviews can compress unit margins. No active major adverse rulings, but always a tail risk.

Insider net selling (last 12M)

Moderate

Insiders sold $783K, bought only $64K in last 12 months — ratio 12:1 sell. Magnitude small relative to mkt cap ($2B) and likely from option exercises / 10b5-1 plans, but no insider buying conviction visible.

Strong balance sheet

Positive

$321.8M cash vs $445.9M debt (D/E 0.39, very conservative). 130+ years operating history, no covenant risk, dividend cover >1.8x. Downside is well-anchored at book value ~$46/sh.

Analyst price target downgrade (Jun 2026)

Moderate

Keefe Bruyette lowered PT from $81 to $77 on 2026-06-28 (rating: Outperform maintained). Stephens upgraded to Overweight at $82 in Feb 2026. Consensus drifting down -5% in last quarter — analyst expectations are normalizing post Q1 beat.

Clean compliance profile

Positive

No SEC investigation, no class action, no short-seller report, no shelf registration filed. 96.9% institutional ownership and broad Forbes "Best Large Employers 2026" recognition. Standard insurance regulatory oversight only.

article

SWOT analysis

Strengths

+Q1 2026 EPS beat consensus by 47% ($0.78 vs $0.53), revenue +28% YoY
+130+ year operating history, Big-4 title insurance franchise
+Conservative balance sheet: D/E 0.39, $321.8M cash, no covenant risk
+Reliable dividend payer: $2.12/yr, 3.13% yield, 1.8x cover
+Diversified revenue mix: title + RES + international

Weaknesses

−Smallest Big-4 — sub-scale vs FNF (7x larger) and ORI (5x larger)
−ROE 8.5% TTM below quality-stock 15% threshold
−Recent equity raise diluted shares +9.1% YoY
−Insider net selling (12:1 sell/buy ratio L12M)
−Lower pre-tax margin (5.7%) vs FNF (12%+)

Opportunities

→Existing-home sales rebound from cycle lows would drive EPS materially higher
→Fed rate cuts in 2H'26 could trigger mortgage refinancing wave
→NCS + Nationwide Appraisal accretion to FY27 EPS
→Commercial title segment record growth — diversification benefit
→AI / virtual underwriter platform enhancements unlock margin expansion

Threats

!Mortgage rates re-accelerate above 7.5% → housing freezes again
!Recession scenario → commercial real estate transactions collapse
!FNF/FAF aggressive tech investments (AI title automation) erode share
!State-level regulatory rate compression in major TX/FL markets
!Sector de-rating if peer multiples compress to long-term avg (~8x)

article

Summary by assessment area

🟢 Financial risk — LOW

Cash $322M vs LT debt; D/E 0.39, well below sector
No covenant risk; dividend cover 1.8x
FY25 net income +57.6% YoY; Q1 2026 momentum sustained

🟡 Valuation risk — MODERATE

Fwd P/E 11x = +15% premium to peer median (9.6x)
FV $72.50 vs price $67.06 = +8% upside, limited margin of safety
Bull case requires Fed cuts + housing rebound (20% probability)

🟡 Cycle risk — MODERATE

Revenue elasticity to housing volume ~1.0x
Mortgage rate sensitivity: 100bps move = ~$0.50-0.80 EPS
Bear case ($50–60) plausible if 2H'26 rates re-accelerate

{ "verdict_label": {"it": "Giudizio: Moderatamente Attraente — Fair value vicino al prezzo", "en": "Verdict: Moderately Attractive — Fair value close to current price"}, "verdict_text": {"it": "Titolo title insurance di qualita' con forte Q1 2026 (rev +28%, EPS beat +47%). Fwd P/E 11x con peer mediano 9.6x: premio crescita gia' prezzato. Upside base +8%, downside ancorato a cassa solida e dividendo 3.1%. R/R simmetrico, non asimmetrico.", "en": "Quality title-insurance franchise with strong Q1 2026 (rev +28%, EPS beat +47%). Fwd P/E 11x vs peer median 9.6x: growth premium largely priced in. Base upside +8%, downside anchored by strong cash position and 3.1% dividend. Symmetric R/R, not asymmetric."}, "bull_points": [ {"it": "Q1 2026: ricavi +28% YoY, EPS adj $0.78 vs $0.53 consensus (+47% beat)", "en": "Q1 2026: revenue +28% YoY, adj EPS $0.78 vs $0.53 consensus (+47% beat)"}, {"it": "Bilancio solido: $322M cassa, D/E 0.39, dividendo 3.1% ben coperto", "en": "Strong balance sheet: $322M cash, D/E 0.39, 3.1% dividend well covered"}, {"it": "Big-4 title insurance USA; cicly play su normalizzazione mercato immobiliare", "en": "US Big-4 title insurance; cyclical play on US housing-market normalization"} ], "bear_points": [ {"it": "Premio del 15% vs mediana peer (FNF 7.9x, FAF 9.4x): poco margine di sicurezza", "en": "15% premium vs peer median (FNF 7.9x, FAF 9.4x): limited margin of safety"}, {"it": "ROE 8.5% TTM sotto la soglia 15% delle quality stocks", "en": "8.5% TTM ROE below the 15% quality-stock threshold"}, {"it": "Sub-scale: piu' piccolo dei Big-4 (FNF 7x, ORI 5x), margini piu' sottili", "en": "Sub-scale: smallest of Big-4 (FNF 7x, ORI 5x larger), thinner margins"} ], "risks": [ {"it": "Sensibilita' diretta ai tassi mutui USA: se 30Y supera 7.5%, EPS crolla", "en": "Direct US mortgage-rate sensitivity: if 30Y exceeds 7.5%, EPS drops"}, {"it": "Diluzione +9.1% da equity raise per finanziare M&A (NCS + Nationwide Appraisal)", "en": "+9.1% dilution from equity raise to finance M&A (NCS + Nationwide Appraisal)"}, {"it": "Insider net selling 12:1 negli ultimi 12 mesi — no segnale di conviction", "en": "Insider net selling 12:1 in last 12 months — no buying conviction signal"} ] }

Sources & Disclaimer

Sources: Stewart Information Services Q1 2026 earnings release (PRNewswire, 2026-04-23) · Q4 2025 10-K filing (SEC EDGAR, 2026-02) · MarketBeat STC summary (2026-06-29) · StockAnalysis.com STC price history (updated 2026-06-26) · GuruFocus / Simply Wall St for peer valuations (FNF/FAF/ORI fwd P/E) · TipRanks (Keefe Bruyette PT cut to $77 on 2026-06-28; Stephens upgrade Feb 2026) · BusinessWire (Nationwide Appraisal Network acquisition 2026-04-02). Market data — last verified close 2026-06-29: STC $67.06 (T-1 trading day), market cap $2.04B, 52W range $56.39–$78.61, ~30.43M shares outstanding. Short interest: ~2.6%. Insider activity L12M: $64K bought / $784K sold. Cross-source verification: MarketBeat $67.06 close confirms StockAnalysis $68.68 Jun-26 close (delta −$1.62 = −2.36% Mon Jun 29 decline). ⚠️ This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice.