hourglass
Loading…
Preparing the latest DD data, styles and content.
62OpportunityDD: Jul 14, 2026Analyst: 72
paidPrice at analysis date
USD 42.9 (14/07/2026)
domainMkt cap
$1.20B
pie_chartShares
27.91M
candlestick_chart52W
10-13
trending_downShort interest
3.2%
INFONYSEFinancials1068 employeesFounded 1990
Verdict: MODERATE — Quality-Value at Cyclical PeakDeep-value P/E 6.4x, forward 9.3x, extraordinary ROE 37.5%, four consecutive earnings beats averaging +36.8%. Q1 2026 combined ratio improved to 89.7% on Florida legal reforms. However, stock has rallied 66% in the past year and now trades near 52-week high ($42.86 vs $43.96 high), 2026 revenue is guided down -3.7% YoY, and consensus analyst target ($40 MarketBeat, $44 Zacks) implies limited near-term upside. Fair value ≈ $41 → stock is approximately fairly valued; catalyst = Q2 2026 earnings on July 23, 2026 and 2026 hurricane season outcome.
📊 DIANALITICS RESEARCH INDEXCompany & Thesis Assessment
Score /100 — updated 2026-07-14
72
Fin. strength
17
/20 pts
EBITDA/FCF
12
/15 pts
Debt/leverage
14
/15 pts
Stage/business
9
/15 pts
Catalysts
5
/10 pts
Reg. risk
4
/8 pts
Risk/reward
3
/7 pts
Management
4
/5 pts
Sector/macro
2
/3 pts
Compliance
2
/2 pts
💡 Fair Value estimate — Blended P/E on forward EPS + Justified P/B (insurance methodology)
Fair value base case
USD 41.0
Range: USD 37.0-USD 47.0
Price at analysis date: USD 42.9 (14/07/2026)
Base upside/downside: -4%
Base FV derived from forward earnings capitalization using peer-median forward P/E adjusted for ROE premium; sensitivity ±$5.10/sh per 1x multiple change. Book-value cross-check confirms within 4%. Scenario weights biased slightly to Base+Bear reflecting that consensus 2026 revenue is guided down and stock has rallied 66% into a hurricane season entry point. ⚠️ Not investment advice.
| Component | Assumption | USD/share |
|---|---|---|
| Forward earnings capitalization | Normalized 2026-2027E EPS ~$5.10 × 8.0x peer-adjusted P/E (HRTG/HCI median 5.5x + 2.5x ROE premium) | +40.80 |
| Buyback accretion (net) | ~$13M remaining buyback authorization at ~$42 avg → ~0.31M shares (~1.1% float) × EPS accretion / share basis | +0.45 |
| Excess capital / dividend yield | Sustained special dividend + regular $0.64 base; NPV of yield premium vs peers ≈ +0.5% p.a. | +0.75 |
| Florida catastrophe tail discount | Probability-weighted hurricane season loss above reinsurance retention ($45M × ~4.5% annual prob = ~$2M/sh gross) | −1.00 |
| FV base case | Sum of rows above | ≈ $41.00 |
Bull
$50–56
Probability: 25%
Mild 2026 hurricane season (no landfall), Q2/Q3 combined ratio <85%, revenue guidance revised up mid-year, geographic diversification accelerates in TX/GA/SC, multiple re-rates to 10-11x forward EPS as insurance sector momentum broadens.
Base
$38–44
Probability: 55%
Normal hurricane season, Q2 EPS beat continues streak but at more modest pace, 2026 revenue lands −3% (in-line with guidance), combined ratio 90-92%, ROE moderates toward 25-28% sustainable level, multiple stays 8-9x forward.
Bear
$26–34
Probability: 20%
Major Florida hurricane (Cat 3+) breaches reinsurance retention twice, combined ratio spikes to 105%+, reinsurance renewal pricing jumps 20% for 2027-2028 renewal, multiple compresses to 6x forward as ROE normalization arrives faster than expected.
Methodology: Base FV derived from forward earnings capitalization using peer-median forward P/E adjusted for ROE premium; sensitivity ±$5.10/sh per 1x multiple change. Book-value cross-check confirms within 4%. Scenario weights biased slightly to Base+Bear reflecting that consensus 2026 revenue is guided down and stock has rallied 66% into a hurricane season entry point. ⚠️ Not investment advice. Not investment advice.
check_circle
✅ Reinsurance program fully secured through 2027-2028
Universal completed its 2026-2027 reinsurance renewal (announced May 28, 2026) and added $352M of multi-year coverage extending into 2027-2028. Retentions unchanged at $45M. Combined with Florida legislative reforms (litigation reduction), the loss ratio has structurally improved and 2026 hurricane season carries a fully financed protection stack.
📊 Capital Structure · Short Interest · Buyback & Dilution
🟢 Short Interest
~3.2%
~0.9M shares short vs 27.91M outstanding. Low short conviction; not a squeeze setup.
🟢 Share dilution (1Y)
−0.7%
From ~28.1M to 27.91M shares. Active buyback + no equity issuance. Cause: consistent repurchase program.
🟢 Buyback
$20M auth.
New $20M authorization Jan 2026; ~$13.1M remaining after Q1 (bought 0.21M sh). Priority: opportunistic repurchase + dividends.
Short Interest — context
Short interest well within P&C insurance sector norms (2-5%). No shorting thesis dominance despite proximity to 52W high. Combined with active buyback and stable insider ownership, capital structure signals disciplined management confidence rather than distressed positioning.
Financial analysis — FY2025 / TTM Q1 2026
Revenue TTM
$1.60B
+3.6% YoY · 4-year CAGR +7%
Net Income TTM
$195.8M
Net margin 12.2% (vs 4% FY24)
EPS TTM
$6.76
+195% YoY · P/E 6.35x
ROE (TTM)
37.5%
vs industry 7.4% — 5x premium
| Item | FY2022 | FY2023 | FY2024 | FY2025 | Guidance 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue ($M) | 1,220 | 1,390 | 1,520 | 1,600 | ~1,540 (−3.7%) |
| Net Income ($M) | −22.3 | 66.8 | 58.9 | 183.0 | ~145–160E |
| Diluted EPS ($) | −0.72 | 2.24 | 2.08 | 6.32 | ~5.10E |
| ROE (%) | −4.5 | 21.2 | 16.5 | 39.6 | ~25–28 |
| Combined Ratio (%) | 108 | 96 | 94 | 89.7 | 90–92 |
| Book value/sh ($) | ~14.1 | ~15.8 | ~16.5 | 19.65 | ~22–23E |
Note: 2022 loss driven by Hurricane Ian ($143M cat losses). Recovery arc from 2023 onward has been continuous. FY25 result inflated by absence of major cat + Florida legal reform benefits; guidance 2026 reflects reversion to more normalized run-rate. Book value CAGR 22-25 ≈ +12% per year.
| Metric | Q1 2025 | Q2 2025 | Q3 2025 | Q4 2025 | Q1 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue ($M) | 388 | 402 | 410 | 400 | 393.6 |
| Diluted EPS ($) | 1.44 | 1.21 | 1.38 | 2.28 | 1.88 |
| Adjusted EPS ($) | 1.44 | 1.23 | 1.36 | 2.17 | 2.00 |
| Combined ratio (%) | 95.0 | 92.5 | 91.2 | 85.0 | 89.7 |
| Net loss ratio (%) | 70.5 | 67.8 | 65.4 | 58.5 | 63.9 |
Financial position and sustainability
Debt-to-Equity Ratio
0.17x
Book Value / Share
$19.65
ROIC (TTM)
24.3%
Combined Ratio (Q1 2026)
89.7%
account_tree
Business model — Florida-anchored Property & Casualty specialist with reinsurance discipline
Concentrated but structurally protected specialty insurer
Universal Insurance Holdings underwrites personal residential lines — homeowners, renters, condo, dwelling & fire — with ~76% of premium concentrated in Florida (Universal Property & Casualty Insurance Company) and expansion into Texas, Georgia, Massachusetts, North/South Carolina and 15 other states. The economic model is: premium collection + investment yield − loss ratio − reinsurance ceded cost. Post-2022 Hurricane Ian and Florida legislative reforms (2023 SB 7052, 2024 additional tort reform), litigation frequency has collapsed and loss ratios have compressed to industry-leading levels (Q1 2026 net loss ratio 63.9% vs 70.5% Q1 2025). Reinsurance program is fully secured through 2027-2028 with $352M multi-year coverage added in May 2026 renewal.
gavel
Legal, regulatory and risk analysis
Florida hurricane concentration
High~76% of premium in Florida. Single Cat 3+ storm hitting SE FL could breach retention. Reinsurance covers losses above $45M retention up to full PML but retention pass-through hits Q results. Actuarial history: Ian 2022 caused $143M net cat losses → −$22M full-year net.
Elite ROE / balance sheet
PositiveROE 37.5% TTM vs industry 7.4%. D/E 0.17. KBRA BBB issuer rating (assigned Apr 2026). Book value/share $19.65 (+24% YoY). ROIC 24.3%. Balance sheet quality is a structural differentiator vs Florida peers.
Reinsurance renewal cost inflation
ModerateFlorida reinsurance market remains one of the tightest globally. 2026-2027 renewal completed with retention unchanged at $45M but pricing details not fully disclosed. Multi-year $352M layer for 2027-2028 signals proactive laddering. Cost pressure could compress net margins by 50-100 bps.
Florida legislative tailwind
PositiveSB 7052 (2023) + subsequent tort reform have durably reduced claim litigation frequency. Q1 2026 net loss ratio improved 660 bps YoY to 63.9%. Management explicitly cited "continuing benefits from the legislative environment."
2026 revenue guidance −3.7% YoY
ModerateZacks consensus 2026 revenue $1.54B vs $1.60B FY25 — first decline since 2020. Reflects underwriting discipline (rate over volume) but weighs on multiple. Consensus estimates flat 60 days (no upward revisions).
Consistent earnings beat streak
Positive4 consecutive quarters of EPS beats with average positive surprise of 36.8%. Q1 2026 beat = +36% ($2.00 adj vs $1.47 consensus). Management guidance historically conservative. Signals systematic estimate-setting discipline.
Analyst consensus divergence
ModerateMarketBeat consensus target $40 (−6.7% from $42.86); Zacks $44 (+2.7%); Piper Sandler $40 (raised from $35, Jan 2026). Divergence suggests limited near-term upside; stock has rallied 66% 1Y and now trades near 52-week high $43.96.
Competitive Florida market pressure
ModerateFlorida P&C market stabilization is attracting new capital + peer capacity return (Citizens depopulation). Could pressure pricing power. UVE's response: geographic diversification outside FL is gradual but ongoing (28% of premium mix from A&H + non-FL states, up from ~22% 2 years ago).
article
SWOT analysis
Strengths
- +ROE 37.5% TTM — 5x industry average; ROIC 24.3%
- +Deep-value P/E 6.35x TTM / 9.26x forward vs industry 12.4x
- +4 consecutive EPS beats, avg surprise +36.8%; Q1 combined ratio 89.7%
- +Balance sheet: D/E 0.17, KBRA BBB rated, book value +24% YoY
- +Reinsurance fully secured through 2027-2028 with $352M multi-year layer
Weaknesses
- −~76% premium concentration in Florida → single-state catastrophe tail
- −2026 revenue guided down −3.7% YoY (first decline since 2020)
- −P/B 2.18x vs industry 1.46x — premium valuation on book
- −Limited analyst coverage (only 3 firms); consensus target divergence
- −Stock rallied +66% in 1Y — most upside catalysts already priced in
Opportunities
- →Florida legal reform benefits continue to compound (litigation ↓)
- →Geographic diversification (TX, GA, SC, NC) reduces FL concentration
- →Multi-year reinsurance lock-in insulates 2027-2028 from renewal shocks
- →Special dividend + buyback capacity as capital compounds via retained earnings
- →A&H segment (28% of mix) growing 9% Q1 — non-cat diversification lever
Threats
- !2026 Atlantic hurricane season (peak Aug-Oct) — active season forecast
- !Reinsurance market pricing inflation could compress net margins
- !Citizens Property Insurance depopulation returning capacity to FL market
- !Zacks Rank #3 (Hold); no upward EPS revisions in last 60 days
- !Potential regulatory reversal if FL political dynamics shift on tort reform
article
Summary by assessment area
🟢 Financial risk — LOW
- D/E 0.17, KBRA BBB rated, book value/sh growing +24% YoY
- Elite ROE 37.5%, ROIC 24.3%, consistent net income momentum
- $195.8M TTM net income covers $20M buyback + $17.9M dividends 10x over
🟡 Business risk — MEDIUM
- FL concentration ~76%; single-state catastrophe tail exposure
- 2026 revenue guided −3.7%; underwriting discipline over volume growth
- Multi-year reinsurance secured — structural mitigant
🟡 Valuation risk — MEDIUM
- P/E 6.35 optically cheap but on peak-cycle earnings
- Near 52W high ($42.86 vs $43.96), rallied +66% in 12 months
- FV ≈ $41 → −4% to fair; base case suggests limited near-term upside
Sources & Disclaimer
Sources: Universal Insurance Holdings 8-K filings Q1 2026 (Apr 24, 2026) and FY2025 (Feb 25, 2026); Yahoo Finance / Zacks Investment Research (Jul 2, 2026 UVE analyst article); MarketBeat (accessed Jul 13-14, 2026); StockAnalysis.com; Stock Traders Daily (Jul 10, 2026); Trefis 52-week high screen (Jul 10-13, 2026); Business Wire press releases (May 28, 2026 reinsurance completion; Apr 30, 2026 KBRA BBB rating). Market data — last verified close 2026-07-13: UVE $42.86 (+1.68%), market cap ~$1.20B, 52W: $21.96–$43.96, shares outstanding 27.91M. Short interest: ~3.2%. Beta 0.72. Adj Q1 2026 ROE 38.5% annualized. This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice.